Portland City Hall, a sandstone Italian Renaissance building with a rounded portico and red granite columns, in downtown Portland, Oregon

Portland Weighs a Fair Share Tax That Would Hit High CEO Pay Harder and Exempt 18,000 Small Businesses

Portland City Council has opened debate on a proposal that would turn the city’s first-in-the-nation tax on outsized CEO pay into one of the steepest corporate surcharges in the country, while wiping the business license tax off the books for roughly 18,000 small businesses. The so-called Fair Share Tax had its first hearing Wednesday, and councilors are scheduled to take a final vote on Dec. 2.

The measure, led by District 4 Councilor Mitch Green and Councilor Angelita Morillo, arrives as City Hall braces for another lean budget year. According to OPB, councilors this year approved layoffs and cut services to close a $170 million shortfall driven by lagging revenue, and city economists expect more of the same next year.

What the proposal would change

Portland taxes businesses 2.6% of their annual profit. Since 2016, companies whose chief executive earns at least 100 times the pay of the median worker have owed an extra 10% on top of their business tax bill, and companies with a ratio of 250 to 1 or higher pay a 25% surcharge. That surtax brings in about $5 million a year.

The ordinance before the council would amend sections 7.02.400 and 7.02.500 of city code to lower the trigger and raise the stakes sharply. Under the plan, a company would pay a 25% surcharge at a pay ratio of 50 to 1, a 50% surcharge at 100 to 1, and as much as 500% when its CEO earns 500 times the median employee or more.

At the same time, the exemption for small businesses would rise from $75,000 in annual gross receipts to $500,000. Green and Morillo say that change alone would relieve about 18,000 businesses of the tax.

The sponsors estimate the expanded surcharge would raise about $88 million a year. Dropping thousands of small firms from the tax rolls would cost the city about $16 million, leaving net new revenue of roughly $72 million annually. OPB notes that figure is based on 2024 business tax data, and the city budget office has cautioned that the real number could swing well above or below that in any given year, since the tax rides on corporate profits.

To illustrate the effect, supporting documents use Starbucks as an example. The councilors cite a reported CEO compensation of $31 million against a median worker pay of $17,000, a ratio of 1,794 to 1. The company currently pays the city about $227,500, a bill that would climb to more than $1 million under the new schedule.

Supporters: big companies should “pull their weight”

“This tax asks the wealthiest corporations who pay their CEOs more than their fair share to pull their weight for our city and to contribute for the public good,” Morillo said at Wednesday’s meeting.

Green framed the measure as a way out of the annual cycle of cuts. “Every budget season we’re tasked with deciding which vital service we’ll need to cut,” he said. “Will it be parks, violence prevention programs, a fire station, housing assistance? Every year, working Portlanders are paying more and receiving less, and we’re coming to a breaking point.”

Some small business owners spoke in favor of the exemption. Lily Burnett, owner of Parkrose Coffee, told councilors the savings were “not make or break” for her shop but that money saved on the license tax “is money that I will be investing in Portland and in Portland companies.”

Critics warn of an exodus

Opponents argued the surcharge could backfire by pushing the very companies it targets out of the city. “Imposing harsher taxes will just drive more businesses out of Portland, along with their tax revenue, and makes new businesses unwilling to locate to the city,” East Portland resident James Donley testified.

Josh Carter, cofounder of the coworking space Upstart Collective, listed corporations that have left Portland in recent years and questioned how much revenue remains to be captured. “I’m not sure what mega corporations you think are still left to tax,” he said. “The money is not there.” The Portland Metro Chamber and the Oregon Restaurant & Lodging Association have both come out against the proposal.

Portland drew national attention in 2016 as the first city to adopt a CEO pay ratio tax, a policy championed by then-Commissioner Steve Novick, who now sits on the council again. San Francisco voters approved their own version in 2020, which raises about $72 million a year, though voters there narrowly rejected an expansion in June.

There is also the question of who gets to decide. In October, the head of the Portland Metro Chamber sued the city over an arts tax increase passed without a public vote, arguing the charter does not give councilors authority to raise taxes on their own. That case is set for state tax court in January, and its outcome could shape whether measures like the Fair Share Tax need to go to voters.

Counting to seven

The ordinance needs seven votes on the 12-member council. It has the backing of the six-member progressive caucus, which includes members of the Democratic Socialists of America, while more business-aligned councilors are expected to oppose it. If the council splits evenly, Mayor Keith Wilson would cast the deciding vote.

The council returns to the measure for its final vote on Dec. 2.

Featured image: Portland City Hall, by Another Believer, via Wikimedia Commons, licensed CC BY-SA 3.0.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Sunlit rock spires of Smith Rock State Park rising above juniper and sagebrush in Central Oregon Previous post Oregon State Parks Plugs a $14 Million Hole With Higher Fees, but a $1 Billion Repair Bill Still Looms